Prof. Andrew Horne's speech
Endometriosis: definition and prevalence
So I hope, everyone here has heard of endometriosis, particularly, because this is Endometriosis Awareness Month. But I think particularly because this is a really common condition, it's said to affect, 1 in 10 women and those assigned female at birth. That's the equivalent of an estimated 190 million individuals worldwide.
Endometriosis is a condition that's defined by the presence of tissue, like the lining of the womb, outside of the womb, outside of the uterus, and that tissue can be found almost anywhere within the body, can be found within under the diaphragm. It can be found on the umbilicus. It can even be found within the lung.
Main pelvic subtypes
But the commonest site for endometriosis is within the pelvis, and there are three, pelvic subtypes.
- The commonest, which accounts for around 80% of the disease that we see is called a superficial peritoneal endometriosis. This is when you get, diffuse endometriosis lesions around the pelvic sidewall.
- Endometriosis can also exist as a ovarian disease. This is a cystic form of endometriosis, often called “chocolate cysts” because they have altered blood inside them. And these cysts appear on the ovaries.
- Or you can choose this as a deep disease. And deep disease is a more fibrotic and nodular disease that often involves the bowel or the bladder
Symptoms and associated conditions
The endometriosis can cause a large number of different symptoms. Probably the most recognized are painful symptoms.
- Painful periods are often very severe and debilitating.
- Pain outside of periods.
- Pain with sex.
- Pain with menstruation.
- Pain on defecation.
But it can also, cause a range of other symptoms such as diarrhea and constipation, other urinary symptoms, fatigue, depression, and around a third of people who experience endometriosis, suffer from infertility, difficulty getting pregnant.
It's also associated with other gynecological conditions out adenomyosis and fibroids. Is associated with other chronic pain conditions, other inflammatory conditions, and in later life, it can put people at greater risk of conditions like cardiovascular disease and also certain types of cancer.
Diagnostic approaches
Endometriosis is diagnosed using a number of different, approaches, a history and examination, is important. Imaging is important. And laparoscopy or keyhole surgery, is often necessary. And this is carried out under a general anesthetic to try and visualize the disease and often take, a biopsy of the disease.
And there are a number of emerging tests which hope to supersede, the invasive nature of a laparoscopy. Both saliva and blood in particular, have been studied.
Limits of current diagnosis
But one of the problems, with the endometriosis, diagnosis is that none of these approaches are particularly effective.
So, for example:
- a clinical history, an examination isn't able to differentiate between the three subtypes of Endometriosis that you can see here.
- Imaging is only effective for ovarian and deep disease and isn't effective to detect superficial peritoneal disease.
- Surgery, of course, is dictated by, access.
- They're often, huge waiting times for patients to have surgery.
- Even with a laparoscopy, sometimes disease can be unrecognized or microscopic disease can be difficult to pick up.
The biopsy, is also not always helpful. It can be complicated by artifacts, and around 50% of biopsies taken for Endometriosis don’t confirm the disease.
I know whilst there's been a lot of work looking at different, biomarkers, sadly none of these have been, validated in such that they can be, brought into clinical practice, at present.
The diagnostic journey
So patients with Endometriosis often have this awful, prolonged diagnostic journey estimated to be around, eight years in most countries across the world.
So they might:
- See multiple different, healthcare professionals in the primary care setting
- Perhaps go to accidents and emergency and casualty departments
- Before they actually see a specialist, a gynecologist.
And even when they see a gynecologist, they might have to undergo multiple, imaging tests. They might see other specialties, before they have a definitive diagnosis. And importantly, before they're given appropriate treatment for the condition.
Treatment approaches
So how is endometriosis diagnosed? Well, it can be diagnosed in a disease specific way if you like. And that can be either by surgery and this is laparoscopic or keyhole surgery to remove, the lesions. Or it can be treated with a range of different hormone treatments.
And the rationale for using hormones is: we know that Endometriosis is an estrogen dependent condition. And if you give hormones that suppress, ovarian, estrogen production, it's been shown to help with this, the painful symptoms associated with the condition.
And alongside that, we often, offer pain management strategies, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory neuromodulator drugs like nortriptyline and pregabalin, and then complementary therapy, if you like, like physiotherapy, psychological, treatments. And then patients themselves often use things like tense machines, heat and cool packs and dietary changes, which I'll talk about in a minute.
Surgery
So let's look, first of all, at surgery for Endometriosis.
Well, the surgery, although it's performed laparoscopically can be either performed by excision or ablation with, for example, late, lace or heat. And there's a huge amount of debate, particularly across the internet, about which of these approaches, is better. And fortunately, at the moment we don't have any evidence for one, above the other.
The other problem with, surgery is of course, it carries risks.
- You have to have a general anesthetic
- Then there's a risk of complications at the time of surgery
- The surgery itself can even put patients at risk of developing, chronic post, surgical pain.
The other problem is that surgery, isn’t a cure for endometriosis, around 30% of patients experience no benefit. And then their high recurrence rates of up to 50%, within five years.
Hormone treatments
What about, hormone treatments for Endometriosis?
Well, there are range of different hormone treatments that can be used. And these includes combined contraceptives, progestin and GnRH agonists and antagonists. And they can be given by a range of different approaches.
But:
- There isn't one particular hormone that said to be more effective than the other.
- They're only effective when they're being taken.
- They all have a range of different, side effects.
- They’re all contraceptive.
And this is often a young population of women who are maybe wanting to have a family and don't want to take something which is not, fertility sparing.
We carried out a survey of patients across the UK, just over, 1500 patients, responded to this survey asking them about these hormone treatments. And this is the word cloud from the question that we asked them: which hormone or medication helped most. And you can see that whilst there is a large number of different, treatments, there isn't one treatment that comes to the fore. And in fact, the evidence would suggest that current hormone treatment leaves about 50% of patients with persistent or recurrent pain.
Self-management and diet
So it's perhaps not surprising that, patients, turn to other treatment strategies, strategy self-management strategies, such as changing their diet.
And we carried out another survey just three years ago now of just under 3000 individuals with Endometriosis across the globe. And you can see that they use a different, number of approaches, in terms of removing things from their diet, perhaps not surprisingly, things like alcohol and, caffeine, processed sugar, ultra processed foods.
And you can see that and these approaches did appear to have an impact upon reducing some of their painful symptoms.
Gut microbiome research
And so, perhaps not surprisingly, there has been a move to look, at gut bacteria in the microbiome. and endometriosis.
So if we look at what, studies have been performed to date, first of all, focusing on animal studies, most of these studies, have used models of induced endometriosis. And this is largely because, mice, for example, the commonest animal that is studied don't actually spontaneously develop Endometriosis, says they don't menstruate. So you have to develop a model of mouse menstruation and then, using that model and induce endometriosis.
The other problem with these studies is:
- They focus largely on disease development and not symptom relief.
- They also use a wide number of different approaches.
- So there's little consistency.
- Whilst there have been some promising, treatments suggested, the studies supporting these have lacked measures of well-being or behavior.
If we look at the human studies, looking at the gut microbiome, there have only been a small number of studies to date, and most of them have involved only small numbers of patients. So they're difficult to generalize.
And again, like the animal studies, they've used a multitude of different, approaches. And whilst there are, larger studies emerging, we don't have a consistent, if you like, endometriosis microbiome pattern as yet.
ENDO 1000 study
But I think things are changing. And one of the studies that we're leading on, in Edinburgh hopes to address this. And this is called the ENDO 1000 study. You can scan the QR codes here if you want to hear a bit more about it and follow the the study on social media.
And with this study, what we're hoping to do is, a recruit a thousand people with endometriosis associate symptoms. And we launched this study. I'm just in January this year. And then we're going to work with them really closely over a period of two years.
They'll record:
- Their symptoms
- Any treatments that they have
- Any changes in their health on our Endo1000 app.
And at the same time, we'll collect, biological samples:
- Saliva to look at their genetics
- Blood to look at their inflammatory profile
- Urine, feces and a vaginal swab to look at their microbiome and their metabolome.
And the idea is that we'll collate all of the information that we collect from the app, from interrogation of these bio samples with data that we'll also collect from a smartwatch, looking at their activity and sleep patterns into this big, resource that we can interrogate to look for patterns that might help, with, another noninvasive, diagnosis, test for endometriosis.
But I think, most importantly, help us identify patterns which can predict the best medical and surgical, and self-management strategies for the condition.